GAMBAS

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

WORKSHOP IN NHA_TRANG , 20-21 september 2000

 

NhaTrang homepage            Gambas Home Page

 

Sustainable aquaculture in the Mekong delta : context and problems 

Introduction
Mr Xavier Nuttin, European Union delegate, Hanoi

Status, techniques and socio-economic efficiency of shrimp culture in Camau 
Nguyen Van Duyen, Fisheries Department of Camau

Sustainability assessment of Mekong brackish water aquaculture, the EC Gambas project 
Dr Nguyen Tac An, ION Director, Dr Jacques Fuchs, Ifremer

Improvement of shrimp farming in Vietnam 
Dr. Kwei Lin (Asian Institute of Technology, Bangkok)

 

Status, techniques and socio-economic efficiency of shrimp culture in Camau

 

The present situation

In the last decade, because of high life and income of the people in the world generally and in Vietnam particularly, consumption demand of aquatic products which are rich of protein, less of lipid and cholesterol are more and more increased, export market is more and more enlarged making the motive for strong development of shrimp culture. According to the forecast, consumption demand of aquatic products in the world increases averagely 3.8 %/year (97.4 million tons in 1991, 115 million tons in 1996, it is forecasted to reach to 120 million tons in 2010). In 1999, the yield of aquaculture in  Camau province reached to 41,564 tons in which there are 26,100 tons of shrimp.). It is expected that the yield of aquaculture will reach to 50,000 tons increasing 20.3 % compared to 1999 in which there are 27,600 tons of shrimp

Proposals for orientation and technical solutions for future years

The development of aquaculture to 2005 aims to contribute the guaranty foodstuff safety and make raw material resources for the process of export fisheries product. The yield of cultured shrimp will strive to reach 90,000 tons of export commodity value reaching 500 millions USD, which should be feasible due to the advantageous natural conditions, land potential, technological standard and management ability. However shrimp culture needs to carry out specific actions in order to succeed its sustainability. The proposals are the following :

better coordinate planning of research institutes and local ones in order to impulse the sustainable development of shrimp culture, without causing environmental pollution.

support projects in parental tiger prawn culture, reproduction of some local dominant species as small shrimp, grouper, oyster…

help local to train technical staff, pisciculture encouraging staff, technicians in order to satisfy demands.

combine efforts with projects within Vietnam and elsewhere in the world in order to provide the necessary information to local communities in the field of shrimp culture

 

Sustainability assessment of Mekong brackish water aquaculture, the EC Gambas project

 

The situation of shrimp farming in Asia

While playing a leading role in farmed shrimps with almost 80% of world shrimp culture production (650000 tons in 1999), Asia suffered drastic collapses at the turn of the 90’s in several countries. The main reason for the decrease of production was identified as deteriorating water quality and the emergence of numerous pathogens. Excessive and unplanned farm development and poor pond management have exacerbated this trend. Aquaculture is so dependent on the health of the environment that it cannot succeed in unsuitable or degraded sites

State of the art on the impact of tropical shrimp aquaculture on the environment

 

Ecological studies

Previous research conducted with the support of EU (STD3/DG12) from 1994 to 1997 has shown that the impact of aquaculture could be best summarised by increased concentrations in total suspended matter, particulate organic matter and sulfate-reducing bacteria. The organic matter either comes from the ponds or is from telluric origin, due to mangrove eradication when building the ponds.

The assessment of the production capacities of given sites (in the Pacific, Indonesia and Vietnam) has been conducted by comparing production data - in tons per hectare - and environmental data. The scale shown below integrates a range of these environmental parameters with shrimp production levels

Socio-economical studies

The results of socio-economics surveys together with official statistical sources offer a synthetic view of a group analysis of shrimp farms. Stocking density appears as the real criterion of technical systems. Four technical systems have been identified and compared in Indonesia and Vietnam: traditional (T), traditional-plus (T+), semi-intensive (S-I) and intensive (I). The relatively low results of the traditional plus system can be explained by the tendency to over-stock in ponds designed and managed to support relatively low stocking density. This increases the risks of high mortalities. In rather well managed traditional-plus ponds the economic performance is comparable to that observed for other technical systems.

Problems to be addressed in the Gambas Project

 

Overall objective

The project aims at promoting the sustainable development of shrimp farming in the Mekong delta while avoiding ecosystem degradation and production collapses. It is intended to have a practical impact on farming communities through local fisheries authorities

Detailed objectives

The project is broken down into 5 detailed objectives:

To confirm on a significant sample of sites quantifiable relationships between shrimp production and ecological indicators,

To analyse farming practices and socio-economics on the same sites

To carry out mapping of mangrove vegetation, soil type and land use, and value them at ecosystem unit level,

To increase knowledge of scientists and local fisheries authorities through a strong involvement in the programme : training courses and workshops,

To provide the Vietnamese counterpart with tools and methods making them able to devise a follow-up development project extended to the whole of the Mekong delta

 

Activities and partners

 

Activity

Institute

Activity 1  Definition of ecological indicators of environmental diagnosis and aquaculture potential assessment

I.O. Nha Trang + Ifremer/Crema + IRD

Activity 2  Practices and socio-economics of shrimp farming

Cedem/Brest + Can Tho University + I.O. Nha Trang + NACA

Activity 3  Ecosystem and land-use mapping and data base

I.O. Nha Trang + Univ.Toulouse + Ifremer/Brest

Activity 4  Integration of results, statistical analysis, production of methodological guidlines, dissemination of results

I.O. Nha Trang + Ifremer/Brest

Coordination, training programme, workshop and seminars

Ifremer/Paris

 

Organisation

2 study areas, Ca Mau An Tra Vinh, with 15 stations located at farm site

at each station data on water, soil, vegetation, socio-economics and zootechnics are collected 4 times over two years

statistical analysis is conducted on the data base

deliverables are a data base, a methodology for environmental monitoring,  guidelines for Mekong delta aquaculture management

 

Improvement of shrimp farming in Vietnam

 

Shrimp aquaculture in Vietnam is featured as follows :

small scale farming, with large surfaces

extensive (one to two animals per square metre)

low productivity (50-300 kg/ha/year)

mixed culture systems (with rice and forest)

natural as well as hatchery produced seed

 

The major problems arising in Vietnam are the quality of broodstock : those travelling from central Vietnam arrive in the delta in a lousy shape, those locally produced (350 hatcheries in the Mekong) also are of low quality. Altogether there are only about 10% survival in Tra Vinh for instance. Concerning mixed activities, the recommendation is rather to separate activities, as washing out of soils by the rain is a threat to surrounding ponds or channels used for aquaculture.